Critical Question #1 // Is Melbourne Fair?

~\\ ADDITIONAL NOTE//~

The feature image above is a piece of artwork. The original image was then appropriated by Jacqui Lambie MP into an anti-burqa ad to air to her Facebook following

I believe that Melbourne is an unfair city filled with social and cultural injustice. However, though the city we live in has a long way to go, making change won’t be difficult if everyone plays their part.

Last Tuesday, during our Youth Law session it was obvious there was confusion about how to act around the police. You’d want to be polite but assertive. Assert your rights but know their powers. And know where to draw the line. I personally, found it confusing and I know others did too. We explored the idea that police are present to protect us yet some individuals have racial, cultural or age prejudice. How can our people feel safe if the ones protecting us could even be the ones setting us up to fall?

It has also been evident that the Media plays a large role in the fairness of Melbourne and Australia. Obviously the media is also influenced by influential people, people of power and money. This means the things we see on TV or hear on the radio are all filtered. For example, we could actually blame negative media influences for the violent hate crimes against Islamic people in Melbourne. ISIS is a tiny minority in the Islamic world and the media tends to portray overseas drama as something that is avidly present in Melbourne. The media’s wide airing of Jacqui Lambie’s (MP) theory of IS using Ebola to reign terror on Australia also means that this is even more likely to happen than it would if Lambie had never spoken to begin with.

This brings to light the emerging fact that many of our country’s politicians, the people who represent us in our country, have no respect for our own people. The mistrust and the mutiny, they all add to our country’s lack of understanding. The ‘typical Australian’ is now upper-middle-class, white, Christian to some extent and certainly not real. These stereotypes are leading our country astray. Australia is forever changing and with Melbourne as one of the most politically democratic and progressive cities, we should be leading by example. We need to be able to meet our electoral candidates before the elections. Are they bias? Racist? Not understanding of others? Condescending? Unwilling? Unmotivated? These are the flaws that aren’t hard to notice, sure nobody’s perfect but our people don’t deserve to be represented by people who don’t represent ALL the people.

Although Melbourne is a generally safe and liveable place, Melbourne is not fair. Melbourne’s society might seem fine but never forget, we’re still on the privileged side of things. We are lucky to be getting an education and to be constantly aware of what’s going on in the world around us. The fact that there are other teens and even adults in our city who never had the chance to get a good education is unfair. The fact there are thousands of adults and children living out in the streets is unfair. Fairness is defined as the condition of being free from bias or injustice. So is Melbourne really fair?

References

http://youthlaw.asn.au/

http://streetsmartvic.com.au/

http://www.smh.com.au/federal-politics/political-news/jacqui-lambie-questions-defence-officials-about-prospect-of-ebolainfected-suicide-agents-attacking-australia-20141022-119ve0.html

http://www.dailylife.com.au/news-and-views/dl-opinion/the-trouble-with-jacqui-lambies-antiburqa-campaign-20140921-10k2iq.html

http://www.sbs.com.au/news/article/2014/09/25/backlash-against-australian-muslims-worsens

in-class discussions, Youth Law session, discussions with peers and family

One thought on “Critical Question #1 // Is Melbourne Fair?

  1. Hi Bec,
    Thanks for your critical question, i have given you 9/12 for your answer.

    Coherence 2/2 – You built a solid argument and supported your contention of unfairness
    Use of evidence – 1/2 you used the example of youth law influencing your opinion. I would like to see at least one more piece of evidence from Galileo!
    Further information 2/2 – your articles on Jackie Lambie supported your argument
    Multiple perspectives – 2/2 You viewed fairness from a multitude of perspectives
    Critical thinking – 0/2 You didn’t question your own opinion! “many Australian politicians don’t respect their own people” how do you know?
    “these stereotypes are leading our country astray” how can you be sure?
    Language use 2/2 excellent answer, very well written

    Well done,

    John

    Like

Leave a comment